10 Best Pumpkin Pies in Connecticut!

Pamper your sweet tooth with Connecticut's top 10 pumpkin pies. From East Hartford to Middletown, check out the Constitution State and savor all its deliciousness. Bite into the delectable and supreme flavors of the pumpkin pies from these quintessential New England spots and enjoy every taste.

Granny's Pie Factory, East Hartford, CT

Gather the family and make heart-warming memories over a slice of Granny's Pie Factory's delectable pumpkin pie. This tasty treat is made with a delightful balance of smooth and crunchy, giving you a reason to devour a slice with those you care about the most.

American Pie Company, Sherman, CT

The American Pie Company in Sherman is the perfect way to fulfill a pumpkin pie craving. This full bakery and restaurant will make your taste buds happy by making their crusts from scratch. Come in today to try their homemade pies and infamous tasty meals. Every bite of a pumpkin pie from American Pie Company is bound to leave you pleased.

Michele's Pies, Norwalk, CT

Dig into tastiness at Michele's Pies. Their handcrafted pumpkin pies are made with the utmost care and precision, each crafted with the 41-time award-winning recipe. Relish in an extraordinary pastry adventure that will have you coming back for generations.

Oronoque Farms, Shelton, CT

This fall, Oronoque Farms brings joy to the table with its seasonal pumpkin pie that will delight with its classic, homemade flavor. Its perfect blend of spices and love will bring a comforting warmth to any gathering. Get ready for an enchanting and delectable holiday season—with Oronoque Farms' pumpkin pie at the center of it all.

Lewis Farms, Southington, CT

Lewis Farm's pumpkin pies are fall favorites. Enjoy the perfect combination of buttery crust and creamy pumpkin blended with classic spices. Every pie is hand-crafted with the same care and dedication since the family's start in 1951. With a fantastic flavor available nowhere else, Lewis Farm's pumpkin pies are a must-have for any occasion.

Cutie Pies, Thomaston, CT

At Cutie Pies, you must try their mouthwatering and affordable pumpkin pies if you have a sweet tooth. Taste deep-dish goodness and treat yourself to a full assortment of fabulous desserts. Get ready to indulge in Cutie Pies' delectable pumpkin pies.

Edge of the Woods Market, New Haven, CT

This pumpkin pie from Edge of the Woods Market is the stuff of legends. Enjoy a classic buttery crust with plenty of pecans and a sweet, gooey filling. Every bite will be a treat, ensuring maximum delight! Get a slice today and savor the flavor of Autumn.

Nonnie's Italian Bakery, Plainville, CT

Nonnie's Italian Bakery has all the traditional pies you know and love. Sample slices or order a 9" pumpkin pie to share with family and friends. Make bigger gatherings unforgettable with Nonnie's Italian Bakery's pie variety trays, pumpkin pies included. Enjoy the perfect blend of pumpkin, spice, and everything excellent.

Sweet Harmony Cafe & Bakery, Middletown, CT

Take the plunge into temptation with Sweet Harmony Cafe & Bakery's signature pumpkin pie. Located in the heart of downtown Middletown, this scrumptious dessert will awaken your taste buds with its rich and creamy flavor.

Harvest Bakery Inc., Bristol, CT

Harvest Bakery's pumpkin pie is a classic treat. This old-style, traditional bakery has been baking mouth-watering breads, rolls, pastries, and pies for decades. Now, you can enjoy a slice of their toothsome and lovingly baked pumpkin pie, filled with sugariness and spice. Treat yourself to a piece of this harvesttime favorite.

This text was created by the author with the assistance of GPT-3, a large-scale language generation model developed by OpenAI. The author reviewed, edited, and revised the draft language to their satisfaction and is fully responsible for the content of this publication.

Select a Connecticut town to find
the Best Things-To-Do and Places To Go around you